ICANN seeks feedback on proposed changes to its review process
CANN’s Review of Reviews Cross Community Group has published a revised draft report and invited further community feedback on its proposed framework for improving the purpose, organisation and conduct of reviews across the organisation.
The Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) has opened a second Public Comment proceeding on its proposed review framework. Published on 12 November 2026, the second draft report by the Review of Reviews Cross Community Group (CCG) reflects revisions made following the first consultation and further work on the proposed system.
The CCG is seeking feedback on the overall framework and its individual components, including whether the proposed system provides an effective and sustainable approach to conducting reviews within ICANN.
The consultation covers the purpose and scope of different review types, their timing and frequency, and the processes for defining and conducting reviews. It also invites comments on the roles and responsibilities of participants, the proposed Reviews Scoping Committee, and the safeguards and threshold mechanisms included in the framework.
The CCG is particularly interested in how these elements interact and whether the framework strikes an appropriate balance between accountability, efficiency and community participation. Feedback is also sought on the resources and capacity required from the community, the ICANN Board and ICANN org to sustain the proposed system.
The review reform process began after the ICANN Board called for the development of a review programme in May 2025, aimed at strengthening the organisation’s accountability, transparency and effectiveness. Following discussions among leaders of ICANN’s Supporting Organisations and Advisory Committees, the Reviews CCG was established under a charter approved by the Board on 5 September 2025.
Its mandate is to conduct a fundamental evaluation of the reviews established under the ICANN Bylaws as a system and propose a refreshed framework.
The CCG published its first draft report for public comment on 25 June 2026. During and after that consultation, it continued testing the proposed framework, refining definitions and developing processes and safeguards. It also considered the feedback received, leading to significant adjustments to the proposal.
The second consultation will inform the CCG’s final report, which is expected to be submitted for consideration by ICANN Supporting Organisations and Advisory Committees no later than March 2027.
The public comment proceeding: Review of Reviews Second Draft Report.
