European Digital Rights raises concerns over proposed EU Data-Retention Rules for satellite communications

European Digital Rights raises concerns over proposed EU Data-Retention Rules for satellite communications

European Digital Rights (EDRi) and its member organisations sent an open letter to the European Parliament and the Council of the European Union expressing serious concerns about draft data‑retention provisions in the European Commission’s proposals for the Digital Networks Act (DNA) and the Mobile Satellite Services (MSS) Regulation.

The letter states that the Commission ‘sneakily attempted to attribute itself the possibility to impose intrusive surveillance, notably data retention and interception obligations, on those satellite operators through opaque procedures’. It further claims that the proposals would allow the Commission to define the modalities of such obligations ‘through a comitology procedure, which is shrouded in secrecy’, describing the discretionary powers as ‘far‑reaching’ and capable of bypassing ‘essential EU democratic processes’.

EDRi and its members refer to settled case‑law of the Court of Justice of the European Union, noting that ‘the general and indiscriminate retention of traffic and location data is a serious interference with fundamental rights, and is incompatible with EU law as a preventive measure for combatting crime’. They argue that introducing data‑retention obligations in the DNA and the MSS is ‘wholly inappropriate’ while the Commission is still conducting an impact assessment of data retention as part of a wider review.

The open letter does not contain a response from the European Commission, the European Parliament, the Council of the European Union, or other parties. The development is relevant to EU digital governance because it concerns proposed regulatory frameworks for satellite‑based communications and the use of a comitology procedure to impose data‑retention and interception obligations on service providers, raising questions about EU Commission surveillance powers and the application of EU case law on indiscriminate data retention.

Source: https://edri.org/our-work/open-letter-edri-warns-of-eus-undemocratic-attempt-to-introduce-surveillance-in-satellite-based-communications/

Go to Top