UN Human Rights Committee says freedom of association cannot depend on state approval

In General Comment No. 38, the Committee clarifies that individuals can form or join registered and informal associations without prior state authorisation. It also warns against restrictions on foreign funding, misuse of counter-terrorism laws and digital surveillance targeting civil society.

UN Human Rights Committee says freedom of association cannot depend on state approval

The UN Human Rights Committee issued new guidance on 19 November affirming that the right to freedom of association does not depend on prior state authorisation or recognition. General Comment No. 38 interprets Article 22 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and addresses restrictions affecting civil society organisations, human rights defenders, trade unions, political parties and grassroots movements.

The Committee stressed that individuals must be free to decide whether to establish or join registered or informal associations. Membership in an unregistered association must not, in itself, be criminalised or sanctioned.

The guidance recognises freedom of association as a cornerstone of democracy and an essential condition for the enjoyment of other human rights. It also protects associations that pursue controversial or dissenting views, including through peaceful civil disobedience. Organisations must be able to investigate and report human rights violations, expose corruption and advocate on politically sensitive issues, even when their positions are unpopular.

The Committee warned against the misuse of counter-terrorism and national security legislation to restrict associations, particularly through vaguely defined categories such as “extremist” or “undesirable” organisations. It stated that organisations and individuals must not be designated as terrorist entities for peaceful advocacy or lawful humanitarian and protection activities. Reporting human rights violations, representing victims and advocating for accountability cannot, in themselves, be treated as threats to public order.

The guidance also addresses restrictions on funding. Associations have the right to seek, receive and use resources, including from abroad, and to cooperate internationally without being labelled “foreign agents” or threats to national security. The Committee noted that arguments based on foreign interference or the protection of national sovereignty are not legitimate grounds for restricting freedom of association under the Covenant.

Digital surveillance is another area of concern. The Committee cautioned against surveillance of associations and their members, including through digital tools, as well as infiltration by covert police or intelligence services. It warned that Internet shutdowns, the use of artificial intelligence and biometric technologies without adequate safeguards, and excessive monitoring of social media and websites can discourage people from exercising their right to associate.

The Committee also stressed the importance of protecting the privacy of associations’ digital activities, including encrypted communications, confidentiality and anonymity.

While acknowledging that freedom of association is not absolute, the Committee stated that restrictions must be exceptional, prescribed by law and necessary and proportionate to a legitimate aim. Forced suspension or dissolution of an association should be used only as a last resort and subject to judicial safeguards.

General Comment No. 38 provides guidance on the interpretation of Article 22 of the ICCPR. The UN Human Rights Committee monitors the implementation of the Covenant, which has been ratified by 175 States.

Go to Top